No Tags Found!


Hi all,

My company is hiring security guards from a contractor, but we are not aware of their deduction of ESIC & PF. We are paying Rs. 3500 per guard plus service tax. According to their income, the contractor should provide benefits for ESIC & PF.

If they are deducting ESIC & PF, are we liable to pay ESIC & PF to the government?

From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(0)
Amend(0)

Dear Rachana,

ESI is contributed from both sides by the employee as well as the employer. It is calculated based on the gross salary per month, and the maximum ceiling is Rs. 10,000 per month. The contributions from both sides are as follows:

Employee Side: 1.75% of gross per month
So, if the gross salary of an employee is Rs. 8,000 per month, then the ESI contribution would be 8000 * 1.75% = 140 Rupees.

Employer Side: 4.75% of gross per month
The ESI contribution would be 8000 * 4.75% = 380 Rupees.

Additionally, PF is also paid from both sides. Both the employer and the employee are required to pay 12% of the basic salary. Out of this 12%, the employer's contribution of 8.33% goes to the Pension fund, whereas the remaining 3.67% goes to the PF Fund itself.

Regards,
Amit Seth.

From India, Ahmadabad
Acknowledge(1)
SH
Amend(0)

Hi Amit,

Thank you for your reply. My question pertains to the security guards I am hiring. If their employer is not deducting ESIC & PF, am I liable for ESIC & PF in any case? I believe (though I am not entirely certain) that even for any repairing charges or any labor charges, the company is required to deduct ESIC.

Regards,
Rachana

From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(0)
Amend(0)

Dear Rachana,

Your company is not directly required to pay these contributions to the government bodies. You are required to check whether the outsourced company is providing these benefits to their employees or not, as these employees are outsourced to you. Therefore, you are required to ask the outsourcing company to provide the returns and all details related to the same.

Regards,

Amit Seth

From India, Ahmadabad
Acknowledge(0)
Amend(0)

Dear Rachana,

You can demand ESIC & PF Challans per month, ESI & PF Nos. of your employees, ESI & PF return, or you can demand ESIC and PF details per month of your employees from your contractor so that you can check whether your contractor is depositing ESI & PF or not.

Regards,
Raj

From India, Gurgaon
Acknowledge(0)
Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-The user reply contains accurate information regarding requesting ESIC & PF details from the contractor to ensure compliance. It is essential to verify the contractor's compliance with ESIC & PF regulations. (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • Hi all, My another query is as per labour law in this situation anywhere am I defaulter? It means can goverment body take action against me if security guards are not getting benefit of ESIC & PF ?
    From India, Mumbai
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-The employer could be held liable for not ensuring ESIC & PF deductions for security guards. Government bodies can take action if benefits are not provided. (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • Dear Amit,

    Your reply to Rachana's query is correct, but now the salary for ESI has been raised to Rs. 10,000.00. If the employees have a gross salary of Rs. 10,000.00, then they are eligible for the deduction and benefits of ESI.

    Dear Rachana,

    You need to ensure that the contractors are deducting ESI and PF from the contract employees' salaries and remitting the amounts to the government. You can request monthly challans from the contractors to verify this. Failure to ensure compliance could result in sole responsibility falling on the employers during inspections.

    Thanks,
    Amit Shah

    From India, Mumbai
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-[The user's reply contains correct information regarding the increase in the salary limit for ESI to Rs. 10,000. Employees with a gross salary of Rs. 10,000 are now eligible for ESI deductions. The advice to ensure contractors are deducting ESI and PF and providing monthly challans is accurate.] (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • Dear Amit Shah,

    Thanks. By the way, I have already specified that the ceiling for ESI is up to Rs. 10,000/- as a gross salary.

    Moreover, dear Rachana, yes, the government body may ask you to produce the documents before them.

    Regards,

    Amit Seth.

    From India, Ahmadabad
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Dear Rachana,

    As a principal employer, you are liable to deposit ESI & PF. If ESI & PF authorities find anything wrong in that position, the principal employer is liable for these payments, and they will instruct the principal employer to deposit the amount. However, the principal employer can deduct the same amount from the contractor's bill.

    Thanks,
    Raj

    From India, Gurgaon
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Hi all,

    All of us understand that compliance with ESIC & PF is a must, and therefore all the contract workers and direct employees must be covered under the act (according to the law). But my question is that in our company, we are appointing various service contractors for providing service on-site. In a few cases, the contractor visits only 4-5 times in a month (2 to 3 people). Are we required to deduct PF & ESIC contributions?

    Regards,
    Arvinder Rawat

    From India, Visnagar
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Hi Rachna, Please go through the answer of Mr. Raj which is very appropriate answer. It is the responsibility of principal employer to ensure the compliance. Regards Satish
    From India, Baleshwar
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-[B]Response[/B]: The principal employer is liable to ensure ESIC & PF compliance for contract workers. Verify deductions and ensure statutory payments. (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • Hi all, ESIC is must for labour covers under the law But what if the employee is not ready to undergo deduction becase i am facing the same problem in my company. Harshada
    From India, Pune
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Dear Rachna,

    Always remember one thing that whenever a contractor is hired, then as a principal contractor, liability remains with you only. So, you have to check whether those statutory compliances are complied with or not. There are ways to have a way out of it.

    From India, Gurgaon
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Dear All,

    Please advise on ESI & PF deductions on contractors' bills. In which conditions should we deduct ESI & PF, what is the deduction percentage on the bill amount, and in which cases should we not deduct the PF & ESI of contractors? Please provide a brief explanation.

    Regards,
    Rakesh Roshan

    From India, New Delhi
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-The contractors' ESIC & PF deduction is based on the relevant laws. Contractors must handle these deductions. You may not be liable if the contractors are managing these contributions correctly. (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • Dear Rachana Gadage,

    Referring to your query on PF & ESI relating to security guards outsourced by your company, you as a principal employer are liable under the PF & ESI Act. The principal employer is not absolved from liability under these Acts if there is any failure on the part of the contractor (security agency company). The best option is to ensure that the contractor is complying with the provisions of PF & ESI.

    Thank you.

    From India, Madras
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-The user reply is correct. It accurately states that as the principal employer, you are liable under PF & ESI Acts even if the contractor fails to comply. Ensuring contractor compliance is key. (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • Dear Amit Seth,

    I want to know if an employer recruits direct employees on a fixed contract rate, do statutory deductions such as PF and ESIC need to be deducted? What about PT and TDS? Will we deduct TDS under section 192 or section 194C as per the Income Tax Act 1961? Since they are fixed amounts and there are no other perquisites. So, please suggest me.

    Thanks in advance.

    Regards,
    Dhiraj

    From India, Mumbai
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-The employer must deduct PF and ESIC for direct employees. TDS should be deducted under relevant sections of the Income Tax Act. PT may also apply based on state regulations. (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • It is very much your company's responsibility to ensure that ESI & PF is deposited for the security guard or any other person working under any contractor in your company. If the contractor's establishment is not depositing, then it is very much your responsibility to pay the deposit. You do not have any excuse for the same.

    Regards,
    MOTHI


    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Hi,

    I'm Niladri, a new joiner in a company that works on quality analysis of raw materials. They hire contract employees from various core areas all over India, mostly from the eastern region, on a daily basis. However, I am unsure about how to deduct ESI for them.

    Please reply.

    From India, Calcutta
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Dear Friend,

    While engaging security services through a contractor or outsourcing agency, the employer has to make an agreement between the employer and the contractor. When entering into a contract, the employer advises the contractor to produce copies of Registration Certificates under the statutory provisions of the Contract Labour (R&A) Act - 1970, EPF Misc. Provisions Act - 1952, ESI Act - 1948 rules within two weeks from the date of commencement of work. The contractor must also submit copies of challans under PF & ESI every month and maintain all statutory records and registers under the provisions of the said enactments.

    If the contractor fails to produce the above documents, the principal employer is responsible for compliance under the provisions of the acts and must deduct the amounts of contribution under PF & ESI from the contractor's account and pay the balance amount to them. Do not engage such contractors and outsourcing agencies without fulfilling the above norms.

    In your second query, if the employer is unable to make the payment of contributions under the provisions of PF & ESI Acts, they are liable to pay the contributions along with penal damages, interest, and face penalties and prosecutions under the said acts. The amounts to be recovered from the employer's movable and immovable properties and also cease their bank account transactions by the department as a defaulter.

    This is for your kind information.

    Regards,

    P.V. Rama Rao

    From India, Hyderabad
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Dear Sirs,

    We employed two persons recently on a fixed salary basis. This is a short-term job outside the factory premises for the fabrication and procurement of certain machinery. The monthly payment is made by voucher. Our factory is covered under PF & ESI.

    Do we need to deduct PF & ESI for these two persons as well? As the job is purely on a temporary basis, the employees are not willing to deduct the same. What is the alternative?

    Learned friends, please help us by giving your opinion.

    -RAPARLA

    From India, Visakhapatnam
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    See their quotation and the breakdown given in it. The first column should pertain to MINIMUM WAGES (as applicable). In the columns that proceed, deductions of ESI & PF would also be there. In the end, it should be the Service charges and thereafter the total figure of Rs 3500/-. Also, ask the Security Service provider to deposit a copy of ESI & PF challans to your department every month. It will ensure that as a principal employer, you are adhering to all statutory and legal compliances.
    From India, Delhi
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-The reply contains accurate information regarding verifying the quotation, checking for ESI & PF deductions, and requesting monthly challan copies. Well done! (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0


  • From India, Mumbai
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-The user's reply is [B]correct[/B]. It accurately states that if the contractor deducts ESI and PF contributions, the company is not liable. However, if the contractor fails to pay, the company becomes liable as the principal employer. The suggestion to ask for returns to ensure compliance is also valid. (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • Friends in Chennai!

    We are experiencing some peculiar hassles in making payment of ESI and EPF contributions in the branches of SBI in Chennai. Though the cheques are presented with the challans well before the due mandatory dates, the staff in SBI do not receive the cheques immediately but ask the messengers to drop it in the drop box. The cheques are cleared for clearance after a week or so and the date stamp of the SBI is also affixed later. When taken up with the Managers, they plead helplessness citing acute shortage of staff as a reason. This happens almost every month. Though reported to ESIC, no action has been taken by them.

    If any others in HR of other companies are experiencing such a difficulty, how do they tackle it? One way out is to make advance payment of contribution to ESIC and adjust the deposit every month.

    What should we do if we are unable to make advance deposit to ESIC due to cash flow problems? Can this be taken up with the SBI Ombudsman?

    Regards,

    S. Krishnamoorthy

    From United States, Roslindale
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Dear Rachana, Most important thing is that you are pay that employee below minimum wages, Your need to check weather the Contractors has registered with PF, ESI, PT
    From India, New+Delhi
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Dear All,

    My company's corporate office is in Mumbai, and the branch is in Chennai. The Mumbai corporate office is registered with an ESIC code number but needs to obtain the ESIC Sub code number in Chennai. Can anybody tell me if we can make payments of Branch ESI in Mumbai?

    Thanks in advance for your help.

    From India, Mumbai
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Principal employers are responsible for the deduction of contractors. Normally, what companies do is they obtain the ESI number of contractors and don't deduct. However, when there is no ESI number, they deduct and pay on behalf of contractors.

    Sudarshan

    From India, Madras
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    I would like to know about labour laws in madhyapradesh. and min. and maz. rate skilled and semi skilled labour rate latest and update. pl give me reply Thanking you
    From India, Indore
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    We are an autonomous body of the Ministry of Agriculture, and we have been managing a security contract for nearly 15 persons for the past 12 years. Almost every year, the contractor has been changed. However, there is one person who has been working under every contractor continuously since then. He is now in need of his Provident Fund (PF) as some of the contractors did not deposit his PF. What is our liability in this situation? Do we need to assist him, considering he requires his money?

    Please help.
    Sunil.

    From India, Pune
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-The company is liable to ensure PF contributions are made. The continuous service by the guard makes him eligible for PF. You should assist in ensuring his PF is deposited. (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • Dear All,

    Kindly let me know if the Company is required to deposit ESIC for the Retainers engaged by the Company for a period of 6 to 12 months, whose TDS is deducted as a contractor (194c) and what if TDS is deducted as professional fees.

    Further, can we employ persons as retainers on a contract basis for temporary sales promotion jobs for our Client in numbers like 1000, 2000, 3000, or should they be appointed as employees only. In this case, should the Ad Agency need to register under Contract Labour.

    Further, please let me know the labor law compliances that a service company needs to do, who is employing more than 3000 employees.

    Seek your opinion, please.

    Regards,
    SVK

    From India, Mumbai
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-The company is liable to pay ESIC & PF for security guards as they are considered employees. Labour laws apply irrespective of TDS classification. (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • Hi Rachna,

    As the principal employer, you are responsible for the deduction of PF and ESI contributions for the contractor's employees if the contractor has their own PF or ESI code. In such cases, you should request a xerox copy of the PF and ESI challan for verification.

    Harshad Patel

    From India, Ahmadabad
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Regarding this contact 9414359895,MR Guruvinder singh ( chief consultants), Bharat personal services,jaipur
    From India, Jaipur
    Attached Files (Download Requires Membership)
    File Type: doc Bharat Personal Services _advertisement.doc (31.5 KB, 116 views)

    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Hi Amit,

    As per the rule, the contribution from both sides is as follows:
    Employee Side - 1.75% of gross/month
    So, if the gross of mine is 7500/month, then ESI contribution would be 7500 * 1.75% = 125 Rupees.
    Employer side - 4.75% of gross/month
    ESI contribution would be 7500 * 4.75% = 356 Rupees. Now, my question is, is the above 125 Rs deducted from my salary as well as 356 Rs is also deducted from my salary on a monthly basis? Both deductions are done from my salary. Is it right? Please reply to me.

    Dear Rachana,

    ESI is contributed from both sides, employee as well as employer. It is calculated based on the gross salary per month, and the maximum ceiling is 10,000 Rs./Month. The contribution from both sides is as follows:

    Employee Side - 1.75% of gross/month
    So, if the gross of an employee is 8000/month, then ESI contribution would be 8000 * 1.75% = 140 Rupees.
    Employer side - 4.75% of gross/month
    ESI contribution would be 8000 * 4.75% = 380 Rupees. Whereas, PF is also paid from both sides. Both the employer and employee are required to pay 12% of the basic salary. Out of this 12% of the employer's contribution, 8.33% goes to the Pension fund, whereas the rest 3.67% goes to the PF Fund itself.

    Regards,
    Amit Seth.

    From India, Ahmadabad
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Here, one thing we want to add is that at the time of the inspection of the books by the ESIC Inspector, he always sees the records of the security guards and related papers. Please ensure to receive the acknowledgment copy of ESIC and EPF deposited on behalf of the Company to avoid litigation.

    Regards, AKB


    From India, New Delhi
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Hi, I'm Virendra. I am newly joining this site. I am working as a Labor Officer in a textile industry where labor adjustment is a main task. However, it is not a professional job for a Master of Social Work (MSW) holder. I want to gain knowledge in HR/administrative work. Therefore, I kindly ask all of you to help me and provide me with a set of all legal compliance forms in various labor acts.
    From India, Ahmadabad
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Hi all,

    I am a student of MBA HR. I was just reading about ESI from this site. I came across this interesting discussion. Please, seniors, clarify for me why security guards would pay for ESI. Often, a security guard's gross monthly salary is less than 10000 per month, like a maximum of 5000/month. So, how are they eligible for such a deduction? Please reply; I want to know.

    Thanks

    From India, Shahkot
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-The deduction of ESIC and PF is mandatory for employees earning below a certain threshold as per the law. Security guards are eligible for these deductions even if their salary is below Rs. 10,000/month. (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • Hi all,

    I am a student of MBA HR. I was just reading about ESI from this site. I came across this interesting discussion. Please, seniors, clarify for me. Why would security guards pay for ESI when often a security guard's gross monthly salary is less than 10,000 per month, like a maximum of 5,000 per month? How are they eligible for such a deduction? Please reply, I want to know.

    Thanks

    From India, Shahkot
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-The ESI Act applies to employees with a monthly salary of up to Rs. 21,000, including security guards. They are eligible for ESI deductions. (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • dear all, ESIC limit is now 15000/- p.m gross salary and if contractor paying salary to guards then only he is liable to pay PF & ESIC for guards.
    From India, Mumbai
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Hi, I wanted to ask whether an employee leaving the organization within a year and a half would be eligible to receive the PF amount deducted from their salary during their employment period. Is there a law stipulating that an employee can only receive their PF and ESI amounts after completing a specific duration in the company?
    From India, Delhi
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-The employee is eligible to receive their PF amount after leaving the organization, regardless of the duration of their employment. There is no requirement to complete a specific period to claim PF. It is based on the total duration of employment. Ensure proper documentation for a smooth withdrawal process. (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • Hi In your case, if your company is already covered under ESI/PF then you must ask your contractor to cover the site employees. Otherwise you will liable as Principal Employer. K Gowri shankar
    From India, Madras
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-The user's reply is correct. It aligns with the legal requirement for principal employers to ensure ESIC and PF coverage for contract employees if not already provided by the contractor. (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • Hai Raj Meritech Amitmhrm Rachana Gadage By your constructive discussion I had learned many things regarding EPF and ESI . Thank you very much. With regards Dhananjay 8095674711
    From India, Bangalore
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    It is not material for ESI whether the casual employees - either employed by the Company or of the contractors - work for a day or more in a month. The employee and employer contribution on the wages earned by them must be remitted.

    As a principal employer, it is the duty of the company to ensure that ESI contribution of the contract employees is paid together with the employer contribution.

    Obtain the ESI code assigned to the contractor. Obtain the statement of employees in respect of whom contribution is paid. Find out whether the contract employees' names who work with your company do figure in the statement.

    Keep this statement as a permanent record to be shown to the Enforcement Officers of both ESI/PF.

    Mind that the ESI and EPF are social security measures and the Companies should strictly abide by the extant rules.

    S. Krishnamoorthy

    From United States, Roslindale
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-The user's reply is accurate and provides detailed guidance on the employer's responsibilities regarding ESI and PF contributions for contract employees. The information aligns with the legal obligations of a principal employer in ensuring compliance with social security measures. (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • Dear Rachna,

    I agree with Mr. Amit Shah. You have to ensure from the contractor's side that they are deducting the ESI and PF from contract employees' salary and paying the same to the government. For that, you can ask for monthly challans from the contractors. If you are not ensuring the same, during the inspection, it's the sole responsibility of the employers.

    Regards,
    Harshad

    From India, Ahmadabad
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    copmpany fired me from job and i file a case in labour court . Till how many days esi facility can I use after leaving job.
    From India, Delhi
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Uttarakhand Dehradun , Rishikesh, Haldwani , Rudrapur , Ramnagar, Haridwar, Nainital me bhi security guard company pf Esi nahi deti

    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)

    Hi Rachana,

    If the contractor is deducting ESI and PF, then the company is not liable to pay the same. However, if the contractor deducts the contribution but fails to pay, then the company is liable to pay since it is the principal employer.

    For your safety, what you have to do is ask for the half-yearly returns of ESI and annual returns of PF. These returns should specify the names of employees employed by the company through the contractor. The company should preserve a copy for inspection.

    Regards,

    Avinash
    Human Resources
    Alwar, Rajasthan, India

    From United States, Benton Harbor
    Acknowledge(0)
    Amend(0)
  • CA
    CiteHR.AI
    (Fact Checked)-The user reply is factually correct regarding the liability of the company if the contractor fails to pay ESI and PF contributions. The suggestion to ask for proof of returns is a good practice. (1 Acknowledge point)
    0 0

  • Looking for something specific? - Join & Be Part Of Our Community and get connected with the right people who can help. Our AI-powered platform provides real-time fact-checking, peer-reviewed insights, and a vast historical knowledge base to support your search.







    Contact Us Privacy Policy Disclaimer Terms Of Service

    All rights reserved @ 2025 CiteHR ®

    All Copyright And Trademarks in Posts Held By Respective Owners.