Agaisnt 4-5 persons Company issue a Chargsheet and Conducting Domestic Enquiry , I am doing as a M.R. now i want to cross examine that person. (Charge sheet issued for misbehaving, assault, and indecent behavior with Higher management)
Can you share with me a list of questions for cross-examine
From India, Thane
1Can you share with me a list of questions for cross-examine
From India, Thane
Hi,
When cross-examining a witness in a domestic inquiry regarding charges of misbehaving, assault, and indecent behavior with higher management, your questions should aim to achieve the following objectives:
Clarify the facts - Obtain specific details about the incident.
Test credibility - Determine if the witness's account is reliable and consistent.
Expose biases - Reveal any potential biases the witness might have.
Identify inconsistencies - Highlight any contradictions in the witness's testimony.
Here are some sample questions you might consider:
General Questions
Background and Relationship
Can you state your name and position within the company?
How long have you been employed here?
What is your relationship with the accused employees?
Witness Credibility
Were you present during the incident in question?
Have you had any previous conflicts with the accused employees?
Are you aware of any reason why the accused employees might hold a grudge against you or anyone else in management?
Specific Incident Questions
Details of the Incident
Can you describe the incident in detail?
What exactly did the accused say or do?
At what time did the incident occur?
Where exactly did the incident take place?
Were there any other witnesses present? If so, who were they?
Behavior and Actions
What were you doing immediately before the incident occurred?
How did the accused behave immediately before and after the alleged incident?
Did the accused say anything specific that you remember?
Evidence and Reports
Did you report the incident immediately? If not, why?
Have you documented the incident in any way (emails, written reports, etc.)?
Is there any physical evidence (e.g., video footage) that supports your account of the incident?
Cross-Examination Techniques
Consistency and Details
You mentioned earlier that the incident occurred at [specific time]. Can you explain what happened immediately before and after this time?
Have you ever contradicted yourself in your statements about this incident?
Bias and Motive
Do you have any personal disagreements with the accused that might influence your testimony?
Have you discussed this incident with anyone else before the inquiry? What did you say?
Reliability and Memory
How clearly can you recall the events of the incident?
Are you certain about the specific words and actions of the accused, or is there a possibility of misunderstanding or misinterpretation?
Closing Questions
Summary and Confirmation
Is there anything you would like to add that you believe is relevant to this case?
Are you aware of any other incidents involving the accused that might support or contradict your testimony?
Review of Evidence
Can you confirm the accuracy of any documents or evidence presented that support your version of events?
These questions are a starting point and should be tailored to the specifics of the case and the witness's testimony. Always listen carefully to the witness's answers and be prepared to ask follow-up questions to clarify any ambiguities or inconsistencies.
Thanks
From India, Bangalore
When cross-examining a witness in a domestic inquiry regarding charges of misbehaving, assault, and indecent behavior with higher management, your questions should aim to achieve the following objectives:
Clarify the facts - Obtain specific details about the incident.
Test credibility - Determine if the witness's account is reliable and consistent.
Expose biases - Reveal any potential biases the witness might have.
Identify inconsistencies - Highlight any contradictions in the witness's testimony.
Here are some sample questions you might consider:
General Questions
Background and Relationship
Can you state your name and position within the company?
How long have you been employed here?
What is your relationship with the accused employees?
Witness Credibility
Were you present during the incident in question?
Have you had any previous conflicts with the accused employees?
Are you aware of any reason why the accused employees might hold a grudge against you or anyone else in management?
Specific Incident Questions
Details of the Incident
Can you describe the incident in detail?
What exactly did the accused say or do?
At what time did the incident occur?
Where exactly did the incident take place?
Were there any other witnesses present? If so, who were they?
Behavior and Actions
What were you doing immediately before the incident occurred?
How did the accused behave immediately before and after the alleged incident?
Did the accused say anything specific that you remember?
Evidence and Reports
Did you report the incident immediately? If not, why?
Have you documented the incident in any way (emails, written reports, etc.)?
Is there any physical evidence (e.g., video footage) that supports your account of the incident?
Cross-Examination Techniques
Consistency and Details
You mentioned earlier that the incident occurred at [specific time]. Can you explain what happened immediately before and after this time?
Have you ever contradicted yourself in your statements about this incident?
Bias and Motive
Do you have any personal disagreements with the accused that might influence your testimony?
Have you discussed this incident with anyone else before the inquiry? What did you say?
Reliability and Memory
How clearly can you recall the events of the incident?
Are you certain about the specific words and actions of the accused, or is there a possibility of misunderstanding or misinterpretation?
Closing Questions
Summary and Confirmation
Is there anything you would like to add that you believe is relevant to this case?
Are you aware of any other incidents involving the accused that might support or contradict your testimony?
Review of Evidence
Can you confirm the accuracy of any documents or evidence presented that support your version of events?
These questions are a starting point and should be tailored to the specifics of the case and the witness's testimony. Always listen carefully to the witness's answers and be prepared to ask follow-up questions to clarify any ambiguities or inconsistencies.
Thanks
From India, Bangalore
Community Support and Knowledge-base on business, career and organisational prospects and issues - Register and Log In to CiteHR and post your query, download formats and be part of a fostered community of professionals.
Check LisCheck List ofr Disciplinary Proceedings Domestic Enquiry 11 Sep 09.doc
DOMESTIC ENQUIRY.ppt